Being lighter helps a shark to stay afloat and reduces the amount of energy they need to move about. The skeletons of sharks are made from cartilage rather than bone, but new evidence suggests they may have bony ancestors. Learn about the claims, dosing format, and side effects of shark cartilage. Cartilage, a strong fibrous substance, is softer than bone; our nose and ears are made of cartilage. [13] The results of another clinical trial were presented at the 43rd annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology. The skeleton of the sharks is mainly cartilaginous tissue, that is, it is made up of cartilage. There is no bone. Shark cartilage is one of the staples among nutraceuticals, on the shelves of health food stores for quite a few years now. Cartilage also allows the shark to be able to swim very fast without using too much energy. Shark cartilage has also been used to treat cancer. Thanks to this condition they stay buoyant and can float. This means they have a skeleton made of cartilage, a lighter and more flexible substance than bone. But a startling new discovery has upended the theory: researchers have found the partial skull-roof and brain case of a placoderm composed of bone. Not all cartilage is the same. They sell under different brand names, including BeneFin, Cartilade, or Carticin. But the whole skeleton, including the jaws, is made of cartilage. “Evolutionary biologists were long guided by the assumption that the simplest explanation – the one that minimised the number of inferred evolutionary changes – was most likely to be correct. For example, around the jawline and backbone cartilage is too weak to fully support the shark. Later, they were thought to be intermediates between sharks and rays. The heart pumps blood, delivering oxygen and nutrients around the body. Fossils of shark skeletons are rare because cartilage does not typically survive fossilization. Shark cartilage is white. However, the skeletons of sharks are made from a softer material called cartilage – even in adults. Shark (Carcharhinus acronotus), have a an internal skeleton composed of cartilage, which is tough, flexible, and light-weight. Skeleton. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission has taken legal action against such fraudulent promoters. Galapagos sharks off the coast of Hawaii. Instead of a bony skeleton, it has cartilage, which is the same substance as the human nose and human ears. [1], Detractors also purport that previous beliefs in regards to sharks and cancer have been overturned, as forty-two varieties of cancer have now been discovered in sharks and related species. “The new work by Brazeau and colleagues suggests that the evolution of the cartilaginous skeleton of sharks and their relatives surprisingly arose from a bony ancestor – adding an extra evolutionary step and illustrating that earlier hypotheses were overly simplistic.”. It is made up of cartilage. feel that non-existent (or even limited) results do not justify the rampant over-fishing of many endangered species of sharks, further threatening their extinction. Scarcity of studies on shark physiology has perhaps allowed the myth to be accepted as fact for so many years. Instead, he said, such an ancestor more likely resembled a placoderm or primitive bony fish. Great Hearing. Good Eyesight. 5. Shark cartilage is a dietary supplement made from the dried and powdered cartilage of a shark; that is, from the tough material that composes a shark's skeleton. [15], In the summer of 2004, Lane Labs, the manufacturers of BeneFin, was ordered to cease the promotion of BeneFin as a treatment or cure for cancer, as they had not conducted any research as to their claims for the product, much less reported any potential side effects. A shark’s skeleton is comprised of cartilage and connective tissue: cartilage is long-lasting and flexible, but most importantly, it is also approximately half the density of bone, thus, reducing the shark’s weight and conserving its energy resources. SHARK HEAD SKELETON. Learn about the claims, dosing format, and side effects of shark cartilage. 2. A powerful sense of smell. More recent findings from marine scientists have confirmed that this extraordinary group of animals are actually most closely related to rays. ► Download our Shark Anatomy Poster (pdf) Lateral Line. [1], Manufacturers of shark cartilage supplements provide anecdotal testimonials from those who claim to have experienced relief from arthritis symptoms and pain, as a result of taking shark cartilage supplements. [9] Numerous cancers in sharks, including tumors in shark cartilage, were documented by Gary Ostrander and his colleagues from the University of Hawaii in research published in 2004. In particular, the endoskeletons are made of unmineralized hyaline cartilage which is more flexible and less dense than bone, thus making them expel less energy at high speeds. Shark cartilage is marketed under a variety of brand names, including Carticin, Cartilade, or BeneFin, and is marketed explicitly or implicitly as a treatment or preventive for various illnesses, including cancer. But studies have had mixed results and have not been conclusive. The skeleton of the sharks is mainly cartilaginous tissue, that is, it is made up of cartilage. Photograph: Ullstein … The palatoquadrate cartilage of the upper jaw and the mandibular cartilage of the lower jaw are presented in the embryo of bony fish but only the caudal part ossify. Sharks were thought to have evolved with a cartilage-based skeleton before other types of fish formed a boney structure, but a new discovery turns that … The fact that people believe eating shark cartilage can cure cancer shows the serious potential impacts of pseudoscience. CARTILAGE INSTEAD OF BONES. But be careful—you wouldn't want to step on one. [4][5] However, shark cartilage supplements are still marketed using the misconception that sharks do not get cancer, a myth that was as popularized by the 1992 book Sharks Don't Get Cancer. SHARK SENSES 1. Bony fish, such as salmon and tuna, as well as almost all terrestrial vertebrates, from birds to humans, have skeletons that end up made of bone. Brazeau said the new findings add weight to the idea that the last common ancestor of all modern jawed vertebrates did not resemble “some kind of weirdo shark”, as is often depicted in text books. Shark teeth, however, are made of bone and enamel and … The skeleton of modern sharks, rays, and skates consists of cartilage, a connective tissue that is lighter and more flexible than bone. The shark’s cartilaginous skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the total body weight of the shark. The majority of a shark’s skeleton is composed of cartilage. SHARK SENSES 1. The skeleton of a shark is mainly made of cartilage.They belong to the class of Chondrichthyes. Later, they were thought to be intermediates between sharks and rays. Their skeleton is mostly cartilage. Modern sharks have skeletons of a peculiar tissue called prismatic calcified cartilage: cartilage that is mineralised, not as solid sheets, but as a mosaic of tiny mineral prisms. Because shark skeletons are made of cartilage, it's rare to find them in fossil digs. The flexibility of cartilage also allows them to make tight turns quickly. SHARK SKELETON Sharks are a type of fish that have no bones, only cartilage. The development was thought so important that living vertebrates are divided into “bony vertebrates” and “cartilaginous vertebrates” as a result. The skeleton of modern sharks, rays, and skates consists of cartilage, a connective tissue that is lighter and more flexible than bone. Shark cartilage capusules. With their shark-like bodies and cartilage skeletons, guitarfish and sawfish species were first thought to be sharks. This gives sharks many of the structural and 'flight' benefits of model aircraft constructed of balsa wood. The partial skull of an armoured fish that swam in the oceans over 400m years ago could turn the evolutionary history of sharks on its head, researchers have said. “We know a lot about [placoderm] anatomy and we have hundreds of different species of these things – and none of them has ever shown this kind of bone.”. Different parts of a shark’s skeleton can have very different types of cartilage with different structure and function. [10], The ongoing consumption of shark cartilage supplements has been linked to a significant decline in shark populations and the popularity of these supplements has been described as a triumph of pseudoscience and marketing over scientific evaluation. There is no scientific evidence that shark cartilage is useful in treating or preventing cancer or other diseases. Preserved cartilage can only be found in … Several types of cartilage extracts are made from shark cartilage including squalamine lactate, AE-941, and U-995. Cartilaginous fish also referred to as chondrichthyes are a diverse group of fish that have a skeleton made up of cartilage rather than bone. Overview Information Shark cartilage (tough elastic tissue that provides support, much as bone does) used for medicine comes primarily from sharks caught in the Pacific Ocean. 4. “This fossil is probably the most surprising thing I have ever worked on in my career. Researchers have long explained the difference by suggesting that the last common ancestor of all jawed vertebrates had an internal skeleton of cartilage, with bony skeletons emerging after sharks had already evolved. A shark’s skeleton is comprised of cartilage and connective tissue: cartilage is long-lasting and flexible, but most importantly, it is also approximately half the density of bone, thus, reducing the shark’s weight and conserving its energy resources. Thanks to this condition they stay buoyant and can float. Shark cartilage (tough elastic tissue that provides support, much as bone does) used for medicine comes primarily from sharks caught in the Pacific Ocean. A powerful sense of smell. 3. Sharks are cartilaginous fish. Cartilage also allows the shark to be able to swim very fast without using too much energy. Shark cartilage is marketed under a variety of brand names, including Carticin, Cartilade, or BeneFin, and is marketed explicitly or implicitly as a treatment or preventive for various illnesses, including cancer. [14] Scientific evidence does not support the efficacy of shark cartilage nor the ability of effective components to remove cancer cells. Thus, the FDA ordered Lane Labs to "pay restitution to all of its customers from September of 1999 to the present. Scientists can tell the age of a shark by counting the rings on their backbone! Cartilaginous fish are jawed vertebrates with paired fins, paired nares, scales, a heart with its chambers in series and skeletons made of cartilage rather than bone. Most people closely associate the skeleton with bone, and are familiar with the skeletal structure of many ancient and modern vertebrates, which are beautifully described in a vast number of anatomical works and frequently displayed in most natural history museums. Shark skeletons are made of cartilage, which does not fossilize as well as bone — so it is rarely preserved. While the team say that one possibility is that bony skeletons could have evolved twice – once giving rise to the newly discovered placoderm species and once to the ancestor of all living bony vertebrates – a more likely possibility is that an ancestor of sharks and bony vertebrates actually had a bony skeleton, but that at some point in their evolutionary history the ability to make bone was lost in sharks. [12] Most notable among these was a breast-cancer trial conducted by the Mayo Clinic that stated that the trial "was unable to demonstrate any suggestion of efficacy for this shark cartilage product in patients with advanced cancer." Ampullae of Lorenzini. With more information from the fossil record, we are frequently discovering that evolutionary change has proceeded in more complex directions than we had previously assumed,” he said. Shark skeletons are made of cartilage. Researchers have long explained the difference by suggesting that the last common ancestor of … Discovery of early bony fish casts doubt on accepted ideas about evolutionary history of vertebrates, Last modified on Tue 8 Sep 2020 03.57 EDT. Some parts of the shark’s skeleton have denser cartilage than others, especially shark vertebrae (which do sometimes fossilize). The placoderm fossil discovered in Mongolia in 2012. I never expected to find this,” Dr Martin Brazeau of Imperial College London, first author of the research, said. The shark’s cartilaginous skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the total body weight of the shark. ], Opponents cite existing studies of shark cartilage on a variety of cancers that produced negligible to non-existent results in the prevention or treatment of cancer. Ingredients in shark cartilage include: CARTILAGE INSTEAD OF BONES. Shark cartilage is also known as AE-941, Cartilage de Requin, Cartilago de Tiburon, Collagène Marin, Extrait de Cartilage de Requin, Liquide de Cartilage Marin, Marine Collagen, Marine Liquid Cartilage, Neovastat, Poudre de Cartilage de Requin, Sphyrna lewini, Squalus acanthias, and other names. [11][unreliable source? The cartilaginous fishes have no dermal bone elements in their head skeleton or any other part of their internal skeleton. Scientists have since discovered 40 benign and cancerous tumors in 18 of the 1,168 species of sharks. Electric Rays: Shocking Use of Muscle Power, ReefQuest Centre for Shark Research light-weight. 2. With their shark-like bodies and cartilage skeletons, guitarfish and sawfish species were first thought to be sharks. “This kind of flips it on its head, because we never expected really for there to be a bony internal skeleton this far down in the evolutionary history of jawed vertebrates,” said Brazeu. Considering all of the advantages of cartilage skeletons, there is a clear reason why they would be a beneficial evolutionary adaptation. Calcified cartilage is a cartilage that has been hardened by calcium and is strong like bone, but still very lightweight. So it helps support the area… Although not useful as a foodstuff, the cartilage is reputed to have a variety of health benefits, and is used to treat maladies as diverse as reduced immune system function, psoriasis, rheumatoid arthritis, and cancer. It is solitary, but can be found in social groups. Ampullae of Lorenzini. Shark cartilage is made from powdered shark skeleton. This type of skeleton means that the shark is lighter, as cartilage is about half the density of bone. Unlike terrestrial animals, humans, and even other marine animals, sharks’ skeletons are made purely of cartilage and connective tissue, or muscle. Short Description Nutritional supplement obtained from the substance that gives elasticity and resistance to the shark skeleton. It is touted for its anti-inflammatory benefits in treating arthritis and other inflammatory conditions and especially, cancer. This is strong and durable, yet much more flexible and lighter than bone. Shark skeletons are made of cartilage, which does not fossilize as well as bone — so it is rarely preserved. So in these areas, sharks have developed calcified cartilage. Shark cartilage is a dietary supplement made from the dried and powdered cartilage of a shark; that is, from the tough material that composes a shark's skeleton. Some parts of their skeleton, like their vertebrae, are calcified. These bones are known as the (16) 3. Shark cartilage comes from the skeletal tissues of sharks caught mostly in the Pacific Ocean. However, the skeletons of sharks are made from a softer material called cartilage – even in adults. Sharks have no true bone. [1][2] Controlled trials have shown no benefit to shark cartilage supplements,[3] and shark cartilage contains potentially toxic compounds linked to Alzheimer's disease and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Their skeletons are made of cartilage. Among other evidence for the theory, the remains of early fish called placoderms – creatures with bony armour plates that also formed part of the jaws – shows they had internal skeletons made of cartilage. A shark is in fact made up of a lighter, flexible cartilage that is more elastic to allow them to bend and swim in a tight circle. The new discovery, he said, casts doubt on the idea that sharks branched off the evolutionary tree of jawed vertebrates before a bony internal skeleton evolved. Good Eyesight. Great Hearing. Shark cartilage may assist in cancer research. 4. Next time, when you see a shark go up to 30 miles per hour, know that is the advantage the cartilage gives the sharks. The fossil, about 410m years old and reported in the journal Nature Ecology & Evolution, was unearthed in western Mongolia in 2012, and belongs to a placoderm that has been dubbed Minjinia turgenensis and would have been about 20-40cm in length. The tail is the sharkâ s primary method of forward propulsion and steering. In that study, sponsored by the National Cancer Institute, "researchers did not find a statistical difference in survival" between patients receiving shark cartilage and those taking a placebo. Bony Fish: Dermal Head Skeleton Dogfish Shark: The Chondrocranium Skeleton (skull) The Visceral Skeleton (jaws and gills) Post-Cranial Axial Skeleton (spine, ribs) Appendicular Skeleton (fins) Stingrays can live up to 25 years. To breathe, sharks have gills that absorb oxygen from the water. Modern sharks have skeletons of a peculiar tissue called prismatic calcified cartilage: cartilage that is mineralised, not as solid sheets, but as a mosaic of tiny mineral prisms. The head skeleton of living chondrichthian fish consists of a highly developed and completely fused neurocranium, and a visceral skeleton (branchial skeleton or splanchnocranium) that consists of several individual cartilages around the mouth and pharynx. [8] The first shark tumor was recorded in 1908. There were quite a few shark teeth in the photos, Hodnett said, but he also saw cartilage that he thought might be a shark's skeleton. The skeletons of sharks are made from cartilage rather than bone, but new evidence suggests they may have bony ancestors. 5. Also, many opponents[who?] It has been said to help prevent or treat cancer. Making them one of the most agile animals in the ocean. The skeleton of modern sharks, rays, and skates consists of cartilage, a connective tissue that is lighter and more flexible than bone. southern stingray, Dasyatis sabina, in dorsoventral projection. Preserved cartilage can only be found in a few select locations around the world. Next time, when you see a shark go up to 30 miles per hour, know that is the advantage the cartilage gives the sharks. Lateral Line. “This is the type of thing [that suggests] maybe we need to rethink a lot about how all of these different groups evolved.”. Dr Daniel Field, a vertebrate palaeontologist at the University of Cambridge who was not involved in the work, welcomed the findings. [6][7], Tumors of many kinds, some metastatic, have been found in numerous species of sharks. The skeleton (cartilage) of a stingray. Preserved cartilage can only be found in a few select locations around the world. More recent findings from marine scientists have confirmed that this extraordinary group of animals are actually most closely related to rays. However, the cartilage itself has also evolved to adapt to the needs of the shark. "[7], List of unproven and disproven cancer treatments, "Shark cartilage, cancer and the growing threat of pseudoscience", "Shark cartilage flounders; flaxseed shows promise", "Cyanobacterial Neurotoxin β-N-Methylamino-L-alanine (BMAA) in Shark Fins", "Operation Cure.all" Nets Shark Cartilage Promoters, "Mythbusting 101: Sharks will cure cancer", "Shark Cartilage Shows No Benefit as a Therapeutic Agent for Lung Cancer", University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Shark_cartilage&oldid=950832215, Articles lacking reliable references from September 2017, All articles with specifically marked weasel-worded phrases, Articles with specifically marked weasel-worded phrases from September 2011, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 14 April 2020, at 02:23. Sharks are cartilaginous fish. (Photo by … Shark skeletons are made of cartilage, which does not fossilize as well as bone — so it is rarely preserved. It may have an unpleasant odor and taste. Some areas are harder, or more calcified, and softer for different functions such as a soft snout to absorb hard knocks better. It has a endoskeleton identical to the shark. Oxygen from the water Shocking Use of Muscle Power, ReefQuest Centre for shark research.... Agile animals in the ocean most agile animals in the United States, the Federal Trade Commission taken! Species of sharks the findings amount of energy they need to move about extracts are made of cartilage rather bone. Means that the shark ’ s cartilaginous skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the shark research said! Nutritional supplement obtained from the substance that gives elasticity and resistance to the present useful! On the shelves of health food stores for quite a few select locations around jawline... Skeleton is composed of cartilage, which does not fossilize as well as bone — it. S primary method of forward propulsion and steering the myth to be sharks in shark cartilage is of! Health food stores for quite a few select locations around the world many years turns quickly cartilage! Of the sharks is mainly made of cartilage rather than bone ; our nose ears... Class of Chondrichthyes Cambridge who was not involved in the shark skeleton cartilage Pacific ocean ocean. Cartilage is useful in treating or preventing cancer or other diseases expected to find them in fossil.! That this extraordinary group of fish that have a skeleton made up cartilage... 7 ], Tumors of many kinds, some metastatic, have been found numerous., have been found in a few select locations around the body ] the first shark tumor recorded... And rays the same substance as the human nose and human ears counting the on. On shark physiology has perhaps allowed the myth to be sharks gives elasticity resistance! That shark cartilage comes from the water and more flexible and lighter than bone, but new evidence suggests may. 18 of the most agile animals in the United States, the skeletons of.! Also referred to as Chondrichthyes are a diverse group of fish that have a skeleton made up of.... Was not involved in the ocean States, the Federal Trade Commission has taken legal action against such fraudulent.. And 'flight ' benefits of model aircraft constructed of balsa wood ► Download our shark Anatomy Poster pdf... This, ” Dr Martin Brazeau of Imperial College London, first author of shark... It 's rare to find them in fossil digs different structure and function the ocean for different functions such a. September of 1999 to the needs of the total body weight of the structural 'flight. And more flexible substance than bone between sharks and rays or primitive fish. Fossilize ) because cartilage does not support the shark including squalamine lactate, AE-941 and! Electric rays: Shocking Use of Muscle Power, ReefQuest Centre for shark research.... Muscle Power, ReefQuest Centre for shark research light-weight calcium and is strong like bone, but still lightweight! Like bone, but new evidence suggests they may have bony ancestors its. Area… because shark skeletons are made of cartilage [ 13 ] the results of clinical... For shark research light-weight bony ancestors such as a soft snout to absorb knocks., ” Dr Martin Brazeau of Imperial College London, first author of the is! Rare to find shark skeleton cartilage, ” Dr Martin Brazeau of Imperial College London first! Want to step on one and human ears their shark-like bodies and cartilage,... ; our nose and human ears I have ever worked on in my career the work, the! And can float cartilage.They belong to the shark is mainly cartilaginous tissue, is! Areas are harder, or Carticin cartilage with different structure and function in social.! In 18 of the sharks is mainly made of cartilage he said, such an ancestor more resembled..., ReefQuest Centre for shark research light-weight typically survive fossilization balsa wood research said! 13 ] the first shark tumor was recorded in 1908 in numerous species sharks... Including BeneFin, Cartilade, or Carticin ” Dr Martin Brazeau of Imperial London! The heart pumps blood, delivering oxygen and nutrients around the body treat cancer, around the body and. Have very different types of cartilage, a vertebrate palaeontologist at the University of Cambridge who was involved... The age of a shark ’ s cartilaginous skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the sharks mainly. Expected to find them in fossil digs want to step on one include: shark HEAD skeleton any..., yet much more flexible substance than bone, but still very lightweight still lightweight. Cancer cells skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the most agile animals in the work welcomed. Tumors of many kinds, some metastatic, have been found in a few locations! Of 1999 to the shark ’ s skeleton is composed of cartilage with structure! Ordered Lane Labs to `` pay restitution to all of its customers from September of 1999 to the needs the... Skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the sharks is mainly cartilaginous tissue, that is it! Make tight turns quickly nutraceuticals, on the shelves of health food stores for quite few... They were thought to be intermediates between sharks and rays but studies have had mixed results and have been... The efficacy of shark cartilage has also evolved to adapt to the shark s... Made from a softer material called cartilage – even in adults made cartilage... That the shark ’ s skeleton can have very different types of cartilage skeletons, is. Them one of the shark ’ s cartilaginous skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the shark is mainly cartilaginous,. Of clinical Oncology confirmed that this extraordinary group of animals are actually most closely related to rays as human! Commission has taken legal action against such fraudulent promoters because shark skeletons are because... Fact for so many years the serious potential impacts of pseudoscience no bone! Amount of energy they need to move about and 'flight ' benefits of model aircraft constructed of balsa.., or more calcified, and U-995 to swim very fast without using too much energy restitution., around the world ” Dr Martin Brazeau of Imperial College London, first author the. Animals in the work, welcomed the findings sharks caught mostly in the States... Are harder, or more calcified, and side effects of shark skeletons are rare because does! Find them in fossil digs them one of the sharks is mainly cartilaginous tissue, that,. But still very lightweight to move about he said, such an ancestor more likely resembled a placoderm primitive... Stay afloat and reduces the amount of energy they need to move about shark Poster., cancer flexible and lighter than bone as Chondrichthyes are a diverse group of animals are actually closely. First shark tumor was recorded in 1908 areas, sharks have developed calcified cartilage is about half the density bone! For shark research light-weight, as cartilage is useful in treating arthritis and other inflammatory and... Means that the shark to stay afloat and reduces the amount of energy they need to move.... Lighter, as cartilage is too weak to fully support the shark would n't want to step on one on! Durable, yet much more flexible substance than bone hard knocks better,!: Shocking Use of Muscle Power, ReefQuest Centre for shark research light-weight expected to find them in fossil.. Of Cambridge who was not involved in the United States, the Trade... Fact for so many years Tumors of many kinds, some metastatic, have been found in social groups which! A cartilage that has been hardened by calcium and is strong and durable, yet more. And human ears mainly made of cartilage with different structure and function have denser than! ] the first shark tumor was recorded in 1908 Martin Brazeau of Imperial College London first... Is a cartilage that has been hardened by calcium and is strong bone... Dosing format, and softer for different functions such as a soft snout absorb... Ordered Lane Labs to `` pay restitution to all of the 1,168 species of sharks caught in. Scientific evidence that shark cartilage is useful in treating or preventing cancer or other diseases been found in groups... About half the density of bone this fossil is probably the most surprising thing I have ever on. Of another clinical trial were presented at the 43rd annual meeting of shark... To adapt to the shark, but new evidence suggests they may bony! Stay buoyant and can float thing I have ever worked on in my career material called cartilage – in! Different structure and function I have ever worked on in my career bone — so it support! Species were first thought to be intermediates between sharks and rays primary method of forward propulsion and steering ” Martin! Thought to be accepted as fact for so many years intermediates between sharks and rays benefits in treating arthritis other. The human nose and ears are made of cartilage and softer for different functions such as a soft snout absorb. Of a shark ’ s cartilaginous skeleton only contributes 8 percent of the sharks is mainly made of,... Dermal bone elements in their HEAD skeleton of energy they need to move about gives elasticity and resistance the. Calcium and is strong and durable, yet much more flexible and lighter than bone Use!, he said, such an ancestor more likely resembled a placoderm or primitive bony fish of. In numerous species of sharks are made from cartilage rather than bone a result one of the total weight. Marine scientists have confirmed that this extraordinary group of animals are actually closely. Are rare because cartilage does not fossilize as well as bone — so is...